Wednesday, November 11

Poll Results -- Groundwater Regulation

Hey! There's a NEW POLL (Ca's water bill) to the right --->

Groundwater monitoring and regulation...

...is a job for government
 57%
58
...is a job for a watershed
 22%
22
...is a job for an irrigation district
 4%
4
...is a job for individual farmers
 5%
5
...is a job for Superman!
 10%
10
...is a waste of time!
 3%
3
102 votes total


Well, 80 percent of you think that groundwater needs to have some form of regulation that's at a level above the current decision makers, and I agree with that. (Oh, and Superman's busy with healthcare reform...)

Bottom Line: Common pool resources (e.g., groundwater) need to be regulated at some level that inhibits the "narrow self-interest of individuals" from harming themselves.Get everyone (overlying the aquifer) in the same room, and come up with rules, norms, etc. (a la Ostrom) that lead to a sustainable use of that resource.

4 comments:

Josh said...

You need to modify your bottom line to add harming others.

David Zetland said...

@Josh -- harming others is filed under "externalities," which is a different -- but still relevant! -- problem...

Josh said...

If it isn't about harming others, then where does a libertarian have the moral foundation to allow government to regulate someone who may hurt only himself?

David Zetland said...

@Josh -- "themselves" People in a common pool situation CAN regulate themselves (a la Ostrom) or ask for govt intervention to solve their coordination/free riding problem.